MoSCoW Prioritisation Method in Agile

Backlog prioritization is essential. Successful businesses know to prioritize based on business value over effort. The items that are on the top of the backlog must always be the ones that bring the highest business value with the minimum of the effort. It is a golden rule in Agile that no Product Owner should compromise.

Backlog prioritization is not an easy task. While coaching the Product Owners, I can see that sometimes it is tough to define the business value and order the backlog items based on the most profitable ones.

How might we prioritize without investing a significant amount of effort into it? The solution I recommend and that is working very well is the MoSCoW method when the Product Owner uses the four categories below to sort the product backlog:

#1. Must-have — urgent items, we know we want to do them, they bring important customer value. The Product Owners will add to this category the most critical and urgent user stories. Here you can include legal requirements, core functionalities, safety-related functionalities.

#2. Should Have — items that are important, but the effort of implementing them is considerable, or items that the Product Owner is not sure of their necessity, or things still need clarifications. These are functionalities

#3. Could Have — ideas that could add customer value to the future, row ideas that need to mature.

#4. Won’t have this time — items that are discarded for the time being, but not completely. With time, the Product Owner might consider upgrading the category of these backlog items.

Do the user stories need to be ready when being assigned to any of the MoSCoW categories?

No. They are used to sort the user stories before being assigned to a sprint. The Product Owner will take the user stories from the top of the must-have list and schedule it for the upcoming sprint. The user stories will follow the usual refinement process of the scrum team.

How do I assign the user stories from these categories to sprint?

You always start with the must-have. When the must-have is empty, you reevaluate. Ideally, you never pull into a sprint, items from a category inferior to must-have.

Should I decide in which category any user story should be?

If you cannot decide, most probably, it means it is not in the Must-Have category, or it shouldn’t be in any category at all. The best will be to put it in the backlog — a 5th category. Usually, in the product backlog, you’ll have user stories that aren’t filtered yet, or you should not look to them for the moment.

What do I put in the “Won’t have this time” category?

The primary skill as a Product Owner (PO) is to learn to say no. That can be very hard sometimes. But the MoSCoW method is convenient in helping the POs to tell “no”: they add the user stories initially in “Could Do”, and with the time, it goes into “Won’t Do this time” and out of the backlog completely. It helps to track the things that we give up for a reason or another.

Must do? — evaluated on each major release

I met product owners who loved so much this method that they were using it as a time horizon:

It was a straightforward way to show to the management where we are in terms of the scope for the next release — the fewer items, the better. But it also gives the big picture of what will come next and the opportunity of reprioritizing if needed.

How many items should I have in each category?

These are working categories. They need to be dynamic. You should have items for a timespan of a maximum of 2–3 months. More than that will make it very hard to manage the categories.

My organization uses the Scaled Agile Framework, how does the MoSCoW method fit into it?

The MoSCoW method is handy while planning your future Program Increments. If you are using SAFe, I recommend you use MoSCoW in 3 steps:

How do I use these categories in the project management tool?

If you use Jira/Asana, Team Foundation Server, you’ll continue to have your sprints on top of the backlog as usual. Between your top sprints and the Backlog section, you’ll create four sprints in this order of importance: Must Have, Should Have, Could Have, Can Have. Under these sprints, you’ll continue to have your backlog category.

--

--

👩🏻‍🔧Orli.ai — Scrum bot for Discord 🎯Agile Coach📍Lille, France, 😱NEW Agile video every Tue: Subcribe to my YouTube channel: shorturl.at/lnxG9

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Anca Onuta

👩🏻‍🔧Orli.ai — Scrum bot for Discord 🎯Agile Coach📍Lille, France, 😱NEW Agile video every Tue: Subcribe to my YouTube channel: shorturl.at/lnxG9